Clover General discussion

[Jief_Machak]

9 minutes ago, Badruzeus said:

Hai @Jief_Machak, any idea how to Boot HaikuOS (with BFS / BeOS File System) via Clover with EFI / UEFI firmware?

https://sourceforge.net/p/cloverefiboot/tickets/626/

Thanks.

What is the problem? Did you try to make a custom entry that point to the haiku boot.efi ?

[Jief_Machak]

3 hours ago, maclinuxG4 said:

with r5120 SIP disable

 

CM = Z170_UD5-TH

 

see with slice plz

listIOr5121.txt

HDEF Property looks good except "alc-layout-id" doesn't exist. I guess ALC kext didn't start.

You can check that with "kextstat | grep ALC"

 

Could you try with this efi ? Check that the version is "5121-jief". Save preboot.log and check that there is no line starting with "ERROR CONFIG PLIST".

If no sound, check with "kextstat | grep ALC" that ALC is indeed not loaded. Try to load it manually with kextutil, to see what it's saying.

 

Thanks.

CloverX64.efi

[Badruzeus]

12 minutes ago, Jief_Machak said:

What is the problem? Did you try to make a custom entry that point to the haiku boot.efi ?

Yes, but it found no Haiku partition. Using Bfs.efi driver built from https://github.com/pbatard/efifs (compiled onto clover's edk2) produces segmentation fault.

Edited August 25, 2020 by Badruzeus

[maclinuxG4]

43 minutes ago, Jief_Machak said:

HDEF Property looks good except "alc-layout-id" doesn't exist. I guess ALC kext didn't start.

You can check that with "kextstat | grep ALC"

 

Could you try with this efi ? Check that the version is "5121-jief". Save preboot.log and check that there is no line starting with "ERROR CONFIG PLIST".

If no sound, check with "kextstat | grep ALC" that ALC is indeed not loaded. Try to load it manually with kextutil, to see what it's saying.

 

Thanks.

CloverX64.efi

 

 the result is hee

   42    0 0xffffff7f849d7000 0x146000   0x146000   as.vit9696.AppleALC (1.5.1) F79A98F0-BA62-3508-B082-53C4C076FAD0 <37 13 8 6 5 3 2 1>

 

Two points:

-one in r5121, the boot is very slow before swithc, that not normal !!!!! (that is not the case in r5120), could check timing ? because i notice that the boot take too time

-two , check modification for injection of element of my config (patch) because there is something bug elsewhere . ( for sound case)

 

i didn t change config, neither kext !!!!! so you wil find quickly where here is a trouble for sounds

(check any patch  ACPI, kernel, device  properties, etc....)

 

slice have  a complet report dawndumper !!!!!!

 

 

Edited August 25, 2020 by maclinuxG4

[Slice]

I booted Z170 with Clover 5121 and I have sound and all is all good.

[Jief_Machak]

1 hour ago, maclinuxG4 said:

one in r5121

It's not the same as 5121. It should display 5121-jief. It's a special version that can confirm that your config.plist is exactly read the same as before. This version contains both code, before and after my refactors I did lately. It's a version I didn't commit.

So did you try my specific efi ? Do you see 5121-jief after booting ?

[maclinuxG4]

27 minutes ago, Jief_Machak said:

It's not the same as 5121. It should display 5121-jief. It's a special version that can confirm that your config.plist is exactly read the same as before. This version contains both code, before and after my refactors I did lately. It's a version I didn't commit.

So did you try my specific efi ? Do you see 5121-jief after booting ?

 

both and same result . no internal sound

[Badruzeus]

Nevermind @Jief_Machak, I got it works with Custom entry pointing to Haiku's BOOTX64.efi but after changed OS "Type" from Other to Linux. I'm not sure why... uhmmb, bcoz BFS on Clover's repo is part of Grub? Or, you just did a wizard thing to make this worked? #IDK but thanks anyway. 

[Slice]

22 minutes ago, maclinuxG4 said:

 

both and same result . no internal sound

It is not an answer. If you want a help you have to do what asked.

[Jief_Machak]

Looks like I've messed up the debug.log badly. Fixing now !

 

It is the direct use of SerialPortWrite instead of DebugPrint that messed up the log. The thing I don't understand is that DebugPrint call SerialPortWrite...

 

Ah ok, not it's not SerialPortWrite fault !

[maclinuxG4]

 

 

 

 

11 hours ago, Slice said:

It is not an answer. If you want a help you have to do what asked.

again, i  make test with r5121.pkg: no  internal sound then 5121-jief  : no internal sound

 

boot is allright without internal all time (no fix yet)

Edited August 26, 2020 by maclinuxG4

[Jief_Machak]

Debug.log fixed.

 

@maclinuxG4 

Did you checked in preboot.log that there is no line starting with "ERROR CONFIG PLIST"?

I really want to find that bug. Not only because it's one I've introduced. It's impossible for devs to test all configs.
You said that you didn't change your config. Please DO NOT change anything except the cloverx64.efi (or bootx64.efi) depending how you boot.

So, let's reboot : 

  - use this clover efi.

  - check when booted that the version is 5121.2-SC.

  - save preboot.log at clover GUI

  - boot

  - send me output "ioreg -l -w0"

  - check or (send me kextstat) that ALC is launched.

 

Are you using the same clover folder for both boot, or do you use a USB stick to boot my CloverX64.efi ?

 

[maclinuxG4]

21 hours ago, Jief_Machak said:

I really want to find that bug. Not only because it's one I've introduced. It's impossible for devs to test all configs.
You said that you did

again with clover configurator i have no ERROR CONFIG PLIST on mine system.

i copy cloverx64.efi ("5121-jief)  into directory  Starting Clover revision: 5121 (master, commit 2607bd4fb) on American Megatrends EFI

 

i boot for prelog

 

kextstat 

   42    0 0xffffff7f849d7000 0x146000   0x146000   as.vit9696.AppleALC (1.5.1) F79A98F0-BA62-3508-B082-53C4C076FAD0 <37 13 8 6 5 3 2 1>

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited August 27, 2020 by maclinuxG4
bug found

[Jief_Machak]

The ERROR CONFIG PLIST is messages you'll have in preboot.log, nothing to do in CloverConfigurator. The messages "ERROR CONFIG PLIST" is not about error IN config.plist, but error in interpreting config.plist by Clover (not Clover Configurator). You only get them with my Clover "5121.2-SC" version. I'm sorry, I forgot to attach it in my last message.

Like said in my previous message, check that version is "5121.2-SC", not "5121-jief". Send me the preboot.log.

CloverX64.efi

[maclinuxG4]

1 hour ago, Jief_Machak said:

I really want to find that bug. Not only because it's one I've introduced. It's impossible for devs to test all configs.
You said that you did

allright, i not sur that  your 5121.2-SC is running. i copy into by EFI, as you say. (strange...)

 

i made debug for r5121 then r5120, and preboot, so you could compare as i say before.

no modification.

 

[Jief_Machak]

18 minutes ago, maclinuxG4 said:

i not sur that  your 5121.2-SC

It's written in the lower right corner. I need the preboot.log generated by this version. Again, it's a special version that do checks that the normal version do not. It's is also slower because of all this internal checks.

 

22 minutes ago, maclinuxG4 said:

i made debug for r5121 then r5120, and preboot, so you could compare as i say before.

no modification.

I know that won't be any modification. If I thought I caught the bug, I'll tell you. I'm just trying to get info from your system. That's why telling me I can use the previous files you posted is useless. Because I did see them and I still don't know where the bug is.

 

24 minutes ago, maclinuxG4 said:

i copy into by EFI, as you say. (strange...)

Copying into your current EFI allows to be sure that it's the exact same config. That's what we want. What's strange ?

[maclinuxG4]

i have try your 5121.2-SC but not boot. (black screen)

 

i restart with another mac os then i restore CloverX64.efi

Edited August 26, 2020 by maclinuxG4

[Jief_Machak]

8 minutes ago, maclinuxG4 said:

i have try your 5121.2-SC but not boot. (black screen)

How long did you wait ?

[netgear]

v5121. If you use an entries for recovery, the boot is blocked, as well as the hide option does not work, while, without the Entries, it starts.
AppleIntelCPUPM always remains active even with the "false" option.

 

 

To have everything working, I have to use 5114

[netgear]

Recovery v5121 Entries:

-

 

[maclinuxG4]

18 hours ago, Jief_Machak said:

How long did you wait ?

5 minutes, no screen .....

@slice @Jief_Machak

Strange, i replace boot, and then ok to clover with special message all test done

here is the file.

 

i got sound with this version, fix

 

 

Edited August 27, 2020 by maclinuxG4

[Matgen84]

@Jief_Machak @Slice

 

Sorry for that silly question: have you planned for Clover to be compatible with Big Sur. It's complicated, I suspect. But I think this is expected by users.

I know your efforts are great, and deserve thanks. 

[Jief_Machak]

3 hours ago, maclinuxG4 said:

5 minutes, no screen ,

Could set debug to true in boot section and send me the debug.log ?

[maclinuxG4]

14 hours ago, Jief_Machak said:

Could set debug to true in boot section and send me the debug.log ?

last log

 

20:125  0:016  ERROR CONFIG PLIST : the field 'CustomUuid' differs in new SETTINGS_DATA
20:144  0:018  ERROR CONFIG PLIST : the field 'RtROM' differs in new SETTINGS_DATA
20:161  0:017  ERROR CONFIG PLIST : the field 'PatchDsdtFind' differs in new SETTINGS_DATA
20:180  0:018  ERROR CONFIG PLIST : the field 'LenToFind' differs in new SETTINGS_DATA
20:203  0:023  ERROR CONFIG PLIST : the field 'PatchDsdtNum' differs in new SETTINGS_DATA
20:222  0:018  ERROR CONFIG PLIST : the field 'LenToReplace' differs in new SETTINGS_DATA
20:240  0:017  ERROR CONFIG PLIST : the fie

 

Edited August 27, 2020 by maclinuxG4
bug found

[Jief_Machak]

Hum. Send me your config.plist. You replace your serial number by "none" if you're worried (but they're free so nobody cares). But please change in place, don't delete anything. Same for your uuids.